Last updated September 14, 2023

If you are not satisfied with your purchase, you can submit a return or exchange for any number of eligible items within fourteen (14) days of purchase if the item(s) is in the original condition and unused. All returned items are subject to inspection prior to processing.

Please note, sale items are marked FINAL SALE – in which case they are not eligible for refund, exchange, or store credit. Please carefully review all product details, including the products shipping description and all sizing information prior to purchasing.

Our online returns website makes returning an item easy and hassle-free. Buttery Sports provides return labels using UPS or USPS for secure shipping and return package tracking. Simply print your shipping label and place item(s) in original packaging. All you need to get started is your order number and zip code. Your order number can be found in your order confirmation email or on the packing slip next to ‘Customer order #’.

Exchanges: To get started on your exchange, please email us at
✓ Once we receive your item, we will inspect the return and process the exchange. Our return center does not hold inventory on an open exchange request so we always recommend sending back the exchanged item sooner than later to ensure you get the correct size.
✓ Customers are only allowed to submit a single exchange per item on their order. You will not be able to submit a second exchange of an already exchanged item.
Returns: To get started on your return, please email us at
✓ If you elect to make a return for refund, the cost of return shipping is $7.50 for any number of items and will be deducted automatically from your refund.
✓ Once we receive your item, we will inspect the return and refund the purchase amount to the original form of payment or issue the store credit to your email on file. Refunds are processed within 1-3 business days of us receiving your items.
✓ We reserve the right to limit returns and to track returns initiated from the same customers or shipping addresses. If we believe that a customer has been or is likely to take advantage of our return policy, we reserve the right to deny returns to any customer.

Unfortunately this can happen sometimes – if your item arrives damaged or incorrect, no need to worry, we’ll make sure you are taken care of. For the fastest resolution, please send us a photo showing the poor quality print or the damaged area of the item and the order number. A request for replacement needs to be made within seven (7) days of receiving the purchase.

Returned to sender is a common policy used by post carriers to handle items that could not be delivered. If an item could not be delivered for any reason, the item would be sent back to our warehouse. We are not currently able to reship these packages.

The following are common reasons for items returned to sender:

* The address does not exist or is incorrect
* The item contains insufficient postage
* The addressee has moved without providing a forwarding address
* The item is refused by the addressee
If you order has been returned and you do not contact support we will process a full refund for the package. If you wish to have the items reshipped, please reach out to support so we can provide a replacement order for any still-in-stock items.

Buttery Sports does not currently honor post-purchase price adjustments to existing orders.